Uncovering a Legacy of Systemic Police Violence in Chicago
The story of systemic police violence in Chicago is one that has remained hidden for decades, yet its impact continues to reverberate through the lives of those who were wrongfully accused and tortured. A new podcast series from CNN’s Omar Jimenez sheds light on this dark chapter, revealing how over 100 individuals were subjected to brutal treatment by the Chicago Police Department’s “midnight crew” during the 1980s and beyond.
This investigation delves into the experiences of several key figures, including James Gibson, who was wrongfully convicted and tortured, and Andrew Wilson, whose guilt for killing two officers was never questioned despite his own torture. The narrative also centers around Jon Burge, a police commander who oversaw these abuses. Through their stories, the podcast explores the broader implications of justice, accountability, and the long-lasting effects of institutionalized brutality.
The Origins of the Story
Omar Jimenez first encountered the story while interning at the Chicago Innocence Project, where he met someone who had been tortured by the infamous “midnight crew.” This encounter sparked a lifelong commitment to uncovering the truth behind these allegations. Over the years, Jimenez worked on various projects, but it wasn’t until 2025 that he found the right opportunity to bring this story to light.
The podcast came about after Jimenez connected with a man who had been wrongfully arrested and imprisoned in the late 1980s and was still seeking justice over three decades later. This connection highlighted the enduring nature of the issue and the need for continued advocacy and awareness.
The Use of the Word ‘Torture’
One of the most striking aspects of the podcast is the consistent use of the word “torture.” Jimenez explains that this choice was deliberate, as it emphasizes the severity of the actions taken by the police. By using the term, the podcast aims to confront the sanitized narratives often associated with police misconduct.
The word “torture” carries significant weight, and Jimenez notes that it is often associated with fictional scenarios rather than real-life events. However, the reality is that torture did occur in Chicago, and it was part of a systemic pattern that went unchecked for years. This decision to use the term serves to highlight the gravity of the situation and challenge the public’s perception of what can happen in American cities.
What is Justice?
A central theme of the podcast is the question of what justice truly means. For some, justice was seen in the conviction of James Gibson for a double murder in 1990. However, when Gibson was eventually exonerated and received nearly $15 million in damages, it raised difficult questions about the value of time lost and the true cost of wrongful convictions.
Jimenez encourages listeners to reflect on their own understanding of justice and how it applies to the world around them. The podcast does not offer a simple resolution but instead invites deeper contemplation on the complexities of the justice system and the lasting impacts of past injustices.
Current Implications
Despite the passage of time, the legacy of these abuses continues to affect the city of Chicago. Recent settlements, such as the $14.75 million awarded to James Gibson and the $17 million settlement to Andrew Wilson’s brother, demonstrate that the effects of this history are still being felt today. Additionally, a $90 million settlement tied to a former police sergeant highlights the ongoing challenges of addressing systemic issues within law enforcement.
These developments underscore the importance of continued vigilance and the need for reform. While progress has been made, the podcast serves as a reminder that the fight for justice is far from over.
Exposing the Truth
The exposure of this scandal was not the result of a single event but rather a series of revelations that gradually brought attention to the issue. One pivotal moment came when Andrew Wilson, who had been tortured after killing two officers, shared his experience. His case provided critical evidence that led to further investigations and the uncovering of other victims.
Jimenez emphasizes that the process of exposing the truth was slow and methodical, with each revelation building upon the last. This gradual uncovering of the truth highlights the importance of persistence and the role of media in bringing attention to underreported issues.
The Role of Witnesses
A particularly poignant moment in the podcast comes when Jimenez recounts his own arrest during a protest in 2020. He contrasts this experience with the lack of witnesses for individuals like James Gibson, who faced similar situations without the benefit of public scrutiny. This contrast underscores the importance of visibility and the role of media in holding power accountable.
Jimenez reflects on how the presence of cameras and witnesses can make a significant difference in how individuals are treated by authorities. He argues that the absence of such visibility leaves vulnerable individuals at greater risk of being wronged without recourse.
Chicago and the National Guard
The podcast also addresses the current political climate in Chicago, where President Trump’s threat to deploy the National Guard has sparked controversy. Local officials have expressed concerns about the potential for government overreach, and many residents are skeptical of the motives behind such a move.
While some residents acknowledge the need for resources to address violence, there is a strong sentiment against the deployment of the National Guard. Community leaders emphasize the importance of investing in local solutions, such as funding for community centers, rather than relying on external forces.
Conclusion
The story of systemic police violence in Chicago is a complex and troubling chapter in American history. Through the lens of the podcast, listeners are invited to reflect on the meaning of justice, the importance of accountability, and the ongoing struggle for reform. As the city continues to grapple with these issues, the lessons learned from the past serve as a reminder of the need for vigilance, compassion, and a commitment to fairness in all aspects of society.
