The opening week of the 2025 college football season has concluded for most Big 12 Conference teams, prompting initial observations and predictions. While a single game provides limited data for comprehensive analysis, certain performances have sparked considerable discussion and speculation regarding team potential and conference dynamics. This report examines some of the more notable overreactions and emerging trends following Week 1 action, acknowledging the inherent uncertainties at this early stage of the season.
Utah Utes quarterback Devon Dampier has generated significant buzz following his debut. The New Mexico transfer showcased impressive accuracy and dual-threat capabilities, completing 21 of 25 passes for 206 yards and two touchdowns while also rushing for 87 yards and another score. Dampier’s performance has fueled speculation about his potential Heisman Trophy candidacy, particularly given Utah’s offensive challenges due to injuries and depth concerns. However, it is crucial to temper expectations based on a single game against UCLA, a team that appears to be struggling early in the season.
Despite Utah’s promising start, the Kansas Jayhawks and Arizona Wildcats have emerged as early favorites in the Big 12. Kansas boasts a potent offense led by quarterback Jalon Daniels and a surprisingly stout defense. Their convincing victory over Fresno State, who subsequently dominated Georgia Southern, further solidifies their position. Arizona, led by quarterback Noah Fifita, showcased a strong defensive performance against Hawaii. The Wildcats and Jayhawks appear to possess the ideal combination of a dynamic quarterback, talented skill players, and a formidable defense.
Conversely, the Kansas State Wildcats appear to be trending downward after a disappointing start. Following a loss to Iowa State in Ireland and a lackluster performance against North Dakota, concerns are mounting about Kansas State’s ability to live up to preseason expectations. Despite head coach Chris Klieman’s impressive track record, the Wildcats seem to be lacking a crucial element, potentially leading to further defeats throughout the season. This early performance has drawn comparisons to the Oklahoma State team of the previous year, which failed to meet high expectations.
BYU’s dominant 69-0 shutout victory over Portland State has sparked speculation about their defensive prowess. While acknowledging that other Big 12 teams may also possess strong defenses, BYU’s performance suggests they could emerge as the conference’s best defensive unit. The Cougars’ dominance against Portland State, despite the Vikings’ struggles, provided a glimpse of their potential defensive capabilities. However, the level of competition must be considered when evaluating this early assessment.
The Colorado Buffaloes, despite their vulnerabilities, are poised to disrupt the season for other teams. While their defense needs significant improvement, their running game and ability to force turnovers suggest they could secure upset victories in conference play. Despite the departure of the high-flying offense led by Shedeur Sanders and Travis Hunter, Colorado’s resilience and opportunistic play could frustrate opponents and lead to unexpected wins.
The Houston Cougars are projected to surpass Cincinnati and UCF in their Big 12 performance this season. Despite facing weaker competition in their opening game, Houston’s dominant victory over Stephen F. Austin suggests a significant improvement under coach Willie Fritz. Although Cincinnati had a respectable showing against Nebraska and UCF won against Jacksonville State, Houston’s overall team performance indicates a potential turnaround, potentially leading to a bowl game appearance and a winning season.
